Five Dynasties (907–960) and Ten Kingdoms (902–978)
After the fall of the Tang Dynasty, northern China, ruled by five short-lived dynasties, plunged into a state of political and social chaos. The corrupt northern courts offered little support to the arts, although Buddhism continued to flourish until persecution in 955 destroyed much of what had been created in the 110 years since the previous anti-Buddhist campaign. The 10 independent kingdoms that ruled various parts of southern China, though no more enduring, offered more enlightened patronage. At first the Former Shu (with its capital at Chengdu) and then, for a longer period, the kingdoms of the Southern Tang (with the capital at Nanjing) and Wuyue (with its capital at Hangzhou) were centers of comparative peace and prosperity. Li Yu, the last ruler of the Southern Tang, was a poet and liberal patron at whose court the arts flourished more brilliantly than at any time since the mid-8th century. Not only were the southern courts at Chengdu and Nanjing leading patrons of the arts, but they also began formalizing court sponsorship of painting by organizing a centralized atelier with an academic component and by granting painters an elevated bureaucratic stature—policies that would be followed or modified by subsequent dynasties.
Landscape painting
In northern China only a handful of painters were working. The greatest of them, Jing Hao (荆浩), who was active from about 910 to 950, spent much of his life as a recluse in the Taihang Mountains of Shanxi. No authentic work of his survives, but it seems from texts and later copies that he created a new style of landscape painting. Boldly conceived and executed chiefly in ink with firmness and concentration, his precipitous crags, cleft with gullies and rushing streams, rise up in rank to the top of the picture. For 150 years before his time, the centre of landscape painting activity had been in the southeast. Jing Hao’s importance therefore lies in the fact that he both revived the northern spirit and created a type of painting that became the model for his follower Guan Tong (关仝) and for the classic northern masters of the early Song period (960–1279), Li Cheng and Fan Kuan.
An essay on landscape painting, “Notes on Brushwork”, attributed to Jing Hao, sets out the philosophy of this school of landscape painting, one that was consistent with newly emergent Neo-Confucian ideals. Painting was to be judged both by its visual truthfulness to nature and by its expressive impact. The artist must possess creative intuition and a reverence for natural subject matter, tempered by rigorous empirical observation and personal self-discipline. Consistent with this, in all the major schools of Song landscape painting that followed, artists would render with remarkable accuracy their own regional geography, letting it serve as a basis for their styles, their emotional moods, and their personal visions.
In contrast to the stark drama of this northern style, landscapes associated with the name of Dong Yuan (董源), who held a sinecure post at the court of Southern Tang in Nanjing, are broad and almost impressionistic in treatment. The coarse brushstrokes (known as “hemp-fibre” texture strokes), dotted accents (“moss dots”), and wet ink washes of his monochrome style, said to be derived from Wang Wei (王维), suggest the rounded, tree-clad hills and moist atmosphere of the Jiangnan (“South of the Yangtze River”) region. The contrast between the firm brushwork and dramatic compositions of such northern painters as Jing Hao and his followers and the more relaxed and spontaneous manner of Dong Yuan and his follower Juran (巨然) laid the foundation for two distinct traditions in Chinese landscape painting that have continued up to modern times. The style developed by Dong Yuan and Juran became dominant in the Ming Dynasty and Qing Dynasty periods, preferred by amateur artists because of its easy reduction to a calligraphic mode, its calm and understated compositional nature, and its regional affiliation.
While the few figure painters in northern China, such as Hu Huai, characteristically recorded hunting scenes, the southerners, notably Gu Hongzhong (顾闳中) and Zhou Wenju (周文矩), depicted the voluptuous, sensual court life under Li Yu. A remarkable copy of an original work by Gu Hongzhong depicts the scandalous revelries of the minister Han Xizai (韩熙载). Zhou Wenju was famous for his pictures of court ladies and musical entertainments, executed with a fine line and soft, glowing colour in the tradition of Zhang Xuan (张萱) and Zhou Fang (周昉).
Flower-and-Bird painting
Flower painting, previously associated chiefly with Buddhist art, came into its own as a separate branch of painting in the Five Dynasties. At Chengdu, the master Huang Quan (黄荃) brought to maturity the technique of “mogu hua” (“boneless painting”, 没骨画), in which he applied light colours with delicate skill, hiding the intentionally pale underdrawing and seeming thereby to dispense with the usually dominant element of a strong brush outline.
His great rival, Xu Xi (徐熙), working for Li Yu in Nanjing, first drew his flowers in ink in a bold, free manner suggestive of the draft script, adding a little colour afterward. Both men established standards that were followed for centuries afterward. Because of its reliance on technical skill, Huang Quan’s naturalistic style (also referred to as “xiesheng”, or “lifelike painting”) was mainly adopted by professional painters, while the scholars admired the calligraphic freedom of Xu Xi’s style (referred to as “xieyi”, or “painting the idea”).
Both men were also noted painters of bamboo, an object that had symbolic associations for the scholar-gentleman and at the same time posed a technical challenge in the handling of the brush. After the founding of the Song, xiesheng artists from Sichuan, including Huang Quan and his sons Huang Jucai (黄居寀) and Huang Jubao (黄居宝), traveled to the new court at Bianjing (Kaifeng), where they established a tradition that dominated the Northern Song period. Xu Xi got greater favour during the Yuan, Ming, and Qing periods.